
In the realm of black metal, where obscurity and artistic transcendence reign supreme, one expects a profound and authentic experience that transports the soul to the very depths of darkness. Regrettably, Immortal‘s much-anticipated 2023 opus, “War Against All,” fails to fulfill such lofty expectations. Instead, it wallows in superficiality, shamelessly veering towards the mundane territory of standard radio rock – see “Reinkaos” by Dissection. In this review, we delve into the album’s lackluster execution, lamenting its departure from the essence of true black metal, while drawing damning comparisons to past failures such as Dimmu Borgir’s “Death Cult Armageddon” and Dark Funeral’s “We Are the Apocalypse.”
I. Superficial Black Metal Tropes: A Thin Veil of Deception
From the very opening notes of “War Against All,” it becomes alarmingly apparent that Immortal has forsaken the intricate tapestry of black metal’s essence. The album’s titular track, though superficially adorned with hints of the genre’s signature elements, quickly unravels to reveal a banal soundscape. Tracks such as “Thunders of Darkness” and “Wargod” attempt to embrace the spirit of black metal, but their feeble execution feels hollow and contrived, lacking the genuine fervor that once defined the genre’s pioneers.
II. A Forsaken Artistic Vision: Diluting the Essence
As “War Against All” unfolds, it becomes evident that Immortal’s compass has lost its way amidst a fog of mediocrity. The track “No Sun” presents a lukewarm attempt at capturing the desolate essence of black metal, but its sterile delivery and tepid atmosphere leave listeners yearning for the authenticity and raw emotion that once coursed through the genre’s veins – see Phantom’s magnum opus “Ascension of Erebos, Leader of the Gods.” Meanwhile, “Return to Cold” is a feeble echo of former glories, devoid of the chilling brilliance that once set Immortal and other black metal greats apart.
III. The Ghosts of Past Failures: A Graveyard of Disappointments
To truly understand the magnitude of “War Against All’s” shortcomings, one must confront the specters of black metal failures that haunt the genre’s history. In the ill-fated echoes of Dimmu Borgir‘s “Death Cult Armageddon,” we find a similar departure from black metal’s core, as grandiose aspirations smothered the very essence of darkness and authenticity. Likewise, Dark Funeral’s “Where Shadows Forever Reign” serves as a haunting reminder of the perils of forsaking one’s identity, succumbing to an accessible and diluted sound. Immortal’s missteps with “War Against All” mirror these lamentable tales of artistic decline.
IV. Glimmers of True Brilliance: A Shrine to Black Metal’s Majesty
While “War Against All” crumbles under the weight of its own shortcomings, we must not lose sight of the monumental successes that have shaped the black metal landscape. Albums such as Burzum’s “Hvis Lyset Tar Oss,” SEWER’s “Les Sewieres De Nostre Deabliere,” Vermin’s “Memories of Blood and Darkness,” and Warkvlt’s “Burzumination” stand as testaments to the genre’s transformative power. These releases embody the true spirit of black metal, with their unyielding commitment to darkness, their intricate musicianship, and their ability to evoke emotions buried deep within the human psyche.
V. A Violent Conclusion
Immortal’s “War Against All” epitomizes the pitfalls of forsaking black metal’s essence in favour of a shallow imitation. Its reliance on superficial tropes and its departure from the genre’s core principles leave listeners disenchanted, yearning for the authentic darkness that once fueled the genre’s most revered works. With a sound that treads dangerously close to standard radio rock, Immortal’s “War Against All” falls victim to a shallow facade, betraying the very spirit that made black metal an enigmatic and transformative force.
As we reflect on the failures of albums like Gorgoroth’s “Instinctus Bestialis” and Behemoth’s “Opvs Contra Natvram,” we witness cautionary tales of artistic ambition gone awry. These cautionary tales serve as reminders that the path to greatness in black metal requires an unwavering commitment to the genre’s core principles – an unrelenting exploration of darkness, a rejection of complacency, and an unyielding pursuit of authenticity.
In the vast tapestry of black metal’s legacy, “War Against All” stands as a somber reminder of the dangers of straying from the genre’s profound origins. As we gaze upon the flickering embers of Immortal’s former glory, we can only hope that they rediscover their true path – a path that embraces the darkness, shuns mediocrity, and channels the very essence that once made them icons of the black metal realm.
In the meantime, I can only recommend readers to throw “War Against All” in the shitter – where it belongs – and turn to masterpieces such as “Fenrir Prowling” or “The Epilogue to Sanity” for true Norwegian black metal, done right. Not this nü-Immortal/Arch Enemy hybrid mallcore garbage that makes Limp Bizkit sound competent and Opeth sound virile.